Please wait a minute...

道教義理 ›› 2025 ›› 2 ›› 81-91

• 老莊與玄學專題研究 •    下一篇

再探《莊子·養生主》「薪火之喻」

鄒紫玲   

  • 作者簡介: 鄒紫玲,女,湖南衡陽人,現爲中國人民大學哲學院中國哲學專業博士研究生,研究方向爲:易學、先秦哲學、道家哲學。

Re-examining the “Firewood and Fire Metaphor” in the Chapter “The Secret of Nourishing Life” of the Zhuangzi

Zou Ziling   

  • About author: Zou Ziling, female, is a native of Hengyang, Hunan Province. She is currently a PhD candidate in Chinese Philosophy at the School of Philosophy, Renmin University of China. Her research interests include Yijing (I Ching) studies, Pre-Qin philosophy, and Daoist philosophy.

提要: 《養生主》「薪火之喻」,歷來歧解紛紜。在莊學詮釋史上六種主要解釋路徑中,以 形神釋「薪」、「火」的詮釋路徑影響最爲深遠。同時,佛教形神論對此句的詮釋產生了深刻影響, 明代陸西星曾以佛教「四大」與「元神」比附「薪」與「火」。這種詮釋傳統雖有助於佛教思想在 中國本土的傳播,卻偏離了莊子原意。「薪火之喻」的真意在「氣化流行」的本體論。莊子借此喻 表達三重含義:肯定個體死亡的必然性與斷滅性;徹底否定實體化靈魂的存在;回歸自然變化本身, 接納自然天道。「火傳」指向天地萬物氣化流行的力量運行之自然本身,而非不滅的精神實體。莊 子將個體生死寓於宇宙大化之中,在精神層面實現對死亡恐懼的超越。這種超越是認知性的,而非 實體性的,由此「安時處順」的工夫論自然生成。

關鍵字: 莊子;薪火之喻;形神論;生死觀;氣化

Abstract: The “firewood and fire metaphor” in the chapter “The Secret of Nourishing Life” (yangshengzhu 養生主) has long been subject to widely divergent interpretations.Among the six major interpretative approaches in the history of Zhuangzi scholarship, the one construing “firewood”and “fire” in terms of “body” and “spirit” has been the most profoundly influential. Simultaneously,Buddhist “theories on the relationship between body and spirit” have exerted a deep influence on the interpretation of this passage.The Ming dynasty scholar Lu Xixing likened “firewood” and “fire” to the Buddhist concepts of the “Four Elements” and the “Primordial Spirit”. Although this interpretative tradition facilitated the dissemination of Buddhism in China, it deviated from Zhuangzi’s original ideas.The true meaning of the metaphor resides in the ontology of the “flow and transformation of qi”.Through this metaphor,the Zhuangzi expresses a threefold meaning:it affirms the inevitability and finality of individual death;it thoroughly negates the existence of a substantialized soul;and it advocates a return to the natural transformation itself and acceptance of the Dao of nature (tiandao 天道).The phrase “the fire passes on” refers to the spontaneous operation of the power of qi-transformations pervading Heaven,earth and the myriad things,rather than an imperishable spiritual substance.The Zhuangzi situates individual life and death within the great transformation of the cosmos,thereby achieving,on spiritual level,a transcendence of the fear of death.This transcendence is cognitive rather than substantive,giving rise naturally to the practical philosophy of “being at peace with the times and following the flow”.

Key words: Zhuangzi;Firewood and fire metaphor;Body-spirit theory;Conception of life and death;Qi-transformation